2023 (20), №3

The Paradox of Labour Productivity: When More Work Doesn’t Mean Better Results (the Case of American Economy)

For citation: 

Minat, V. N. (2023). The Paradox of Labour Productivity: When More Work Doesn’t Mean Better Results (the Case of American Economy). AlterEconomics, 20(3), 603–620. https://doi.org/10.31063/AlterEconomics/2023.20-3.6


This study aims to provide a theoretical and empirical assessment of the influence of increased work intensity, physical strain, and repetitive tasks on labour productivity in different sectors of the US economy over an extended period. Employing an index-based methodology, we present a comparative analysis of changes in these factors from 1901 to 2020, using indicators and standards provided by the US Bureau of Labour Statistics. The findings reveal a paradoxical trend of slowing and, in some cases, declining labour productivity growth in specific sectors of the American economy. Our research hypothesis focuses on the paradox created by employers valuing employees’ time as a continuously acquired resource, resulting in increased “meaningless work”. This leads to stagnant labour productivity, requiring longer working hours as a solution. Empirical evidence confirms our hypothesis: in sectors involving material production and socially significant services, the limits of labour intensity and effort play a big role in reducing overall labour productivity. This happens independently of factors like capital and technology. On the other hand, in most commercial sectors like trade and various services, labour productivity steadily grows. These sectors efficiently use both intensive and extensive aspects of human effort per unit of time worked. The adverse impact of the proliferation of “meaningless work” is particularly noticeable in socially significant service industries, in the transport and warehousing sector in the United States. Through an examination of labour productivity trends across different sectors of the US economy, this study sheds light on the prospects of harnessing human potential within the context of structural adjustments.

PDF full
Downloaded: 29

Valery N. Minat — Cand. Sci. (Geography), Associate Professor, Associate Professor of the Department of Economics and Management, Ryazan State Agrotechnological University named after P. A. Kostychev; https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8787-4274 (1, Kostycheva St., Ryazan, 390044, Russian Federation; e-mail: minat.valera@yandex.ru).

Åkerstedt, T., & Kecklund, G. (2005). The Future of Work Hours — the European View. Industrial Health, 43 (1), 80–84. https://doi.org/10.2486/indhealth.43.80

Ansell, R., & Mallinz, J. (2021). COVID-19 i dvizhenie rabochih mest v SShA v 2020 g. [COVID-19 and the 2020 US Jobs Movement]. Ekonomist [Economist], 7, 44–79. (In Russ.)

Atkinson, R. (2022). Sektoral’naya politika dlya stimulirovaniya rosta proizvoditel’nosti [Sectoral Policies to Stimulate Productivity Growth]. Ekonomist [Economist], 10, 76–87. (In Russ.)

Bowman, J. R. (2014). Capitalism Compared: Welfare, Work, and Business. Los Angeles: CQ Press, 376.

Crary, J. (2021). 24/7. Pozdnij kapitalizm i celi sna [24/7. Late Capitalism and the Ends of Sleep]. Translated from English by A. Vasilyev. In A. Smirnov (Ed.). Moscow, Russia: HSE Publishing House, 136. (In Russ.)

Dao, M., Das, M., Koczan, Z., & Lian, W. (2017). Why is Labor Receiving a Smaller Share of Global Income? Theory and Empirical Evidence. IMF Working papers, 2017 (169), 70. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3030759

DeMarco, T. (2001). Slack, Getting Past Burnout, Busywork, and the Myth of Total Efficiency. New York: Broadway Books, 240.

Dufour, M., & Russell, E. (2015). Why isnʼt Productivity More Popular? A Bargaining Power Approach to the Pay/Productivity Linkage in Canada. International Productivity Monitor, 28, 47–62.

Eldridge, L., Babilonia, S., Palmer, D., Stewart, D., & Varghese, D. (2022). Utochnennyy metod otsenki otrabotannykh chasov dlya izmereniya proizvoditel’nosti [A Refined Method for Estimating Hours worked to Measure Productivity]. Ekonomist [Economist], 11, 31–60. (In Russ.)

Fearon, J. D. (2003). Ethnic and Cultural Diversity by Country. Journal of Economic Growth, 8 (2), 195–222. https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1024419522867

Finnigan, R., & Hale, J. M. (2018). Working 9 to 5? Union Membership and Work Hours and Schedules. Social Forces, 96 (4), 1541–1568. https://doi.org/10.1093/sf/sox101

Fischer, F. M., Puttonen, S., & Skene, D. J. (2014). 21st International Symposium on Shiftwork and Working Time: The 24/7 Society From chronobiology to practical life. Chronobiology International, 31 (10), 1093–1099. https://doi.org/10.3109/07420528.2014.979600

Freeman, R. B., Pecci, L., & Piga, G. (2008). Why Do We Work More Than Keynes Expected? Revisiting Keynes: Economic Possibilities for Our Grandchildren (pp. 135–142). Cambridge: MIT Press. https://doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/9780262162494.003.0010

Graeber, D. (2020). Bredovaya rabota. Traktat o rasprostranenii bessmyslennogo truda [Bullshit Jobs: A Theory]. Translated from English by A. Aramyan, K. Mitroshenkov. In G. Yudina (Ed.). Moscow, Russia: Ad Marginem Press, 440. (In Russ.)

Guerriero, M. (2019). The Labor Share of Income Around the World: Evidence from a Panel Dataset. In Fields, G., Paul, S. (Eds.). Labor Income Share in Asia. ADB Institute Series on Development Economics. Singapore: Springer, 38.

Kendrick, J. W. (1967). Tendencii proizvoditel’nosti v SShA [Productivity Trends in the United States]. Translated from English by S. A. Batasov. In Ya. B. Kvash (Ed.). Moscow, Russia: Statistika, 315. (In Russ.)

Khabibullina, Z. R. (2020). Tvorcheskij trud: specifika, dinamika razvitiya i harakteristika sistemnoj transformacii [Creative Labor: Distinctive Aspects, Dynamics of Development and Characteristics of System Transformation]. Ekonomicheskaya nauka sovremennoj Rossii [Economiics of Contermporary Russia], 1 (88), 32–40. https://doi.org/10.33293/1609-1442-2020-1(88)-32-40 (In Russ.)

Klavdienko, V. (2022). Raspredelenie pervichnykh dokhodov mezhdu trudom i kapitalom: novye trendy v mirovoy ekonomike [The Distribution of Primary Income between Labour and Capital: New Trends in the World economy]. Obshchestvo i ekonomika [Society and Economics], 5, 47–58. https://doi.org/10.31857/S020736760020121-2 (In Russ.)

Kleiner, G. B. (2021). Sistemnaya ekonomika: shagi razvitiya [System Economics: Development Steps]. Moscow, Russia: “Scientific Library”, 746. (In Russ.)

Kleiner, G. B. (Ed.) (2011). Mezoekonomika razvitiya [Mesoeconomics of Development]. Moscow, Russia: Nauka, 804. (In Russ.)

Kleiner, G. B., & Rybachuk, M. A. (2017). Sistemnaya sbalansirovannost’ ekonomiki [System Balance of the Economy]. Moscow, Russia: “Scientific Library”, 320. (In Russ.)

Knyazev, Yu. K. (2019). Paradoksy proizvoditel’nosti truda [The paradoxes of labour productivity]. Obshchestvo i ekonomika [Society and Economics], 10, 39–61. https://doi.org/10.31857/S020736760007149-2

Krugman, P. (1997). The Age of Diminished Expectations: U.S. Economic Policy in the 1990s. Cambridge: MA: MIT Press, 232.

Kuchinskiy, Yu. (1948). Istoriya usloviy truda v SShA s 1789 po 1947 g. [History of Working Conditions in the United States from 1789 to 1947]. Translated from German. Moscow, Russia: Foreign Languages Publishing House, 396. (In Russ.)

Leijonhufvud, A., Pecci, L., & Piga, G. (2008). Spreading the Bread Thin on the Butter. In Lorenzo Pecchi, Gustavo Piga (Eds.). Revisiting Keynes: Economic Possibilities for Our Grandchildren (pp. 116–124). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. https://doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/9780262162494.003.0008

LePatner, B. B., Wright, R. E., & Jacobson, T. C. (2008). Broken Buildings, Busted Budgets: How to Fix Americaʼs Trillion Dollar Construction Industry. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 242.

Lombardi, D. A., Folkard, S., Willetts, J. L., & Smith, G. S. (2010). Daily Sleep, Weekly Working Hours, and Risk of Work-Related Injury: US National Health Interview Survey (2004–2008). Chronobiology International, 27 (5), 1013–1030. https://doi.org/10.3109/07420528.2010.489466

Maevsky, V. I., & Kirdina-Chandler, S. G. (Eds.) (2020). Mezoekonomika: elementy novoy paradigmy [Mesoeconomics: Elements of a New Paradigm]. Monograph. Moscow, Russia: Institute of Economics of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 392. (In Russ.)

Marucci-Wellman, H. R., Tin-Chi, L, Willetts, J. L., Brennan, M. J., & Santosh, K. V. (2014). Differences in Time Use and Activity Patterns When Adding a Second Job: Implications for Health and Safety in the United States. American Journal of Public Health, August, 104 (8), 1488–1500. https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.2014.301921

Minat, V. N. (2022). Etno-demograficheskaya neodnorodnost’ i social’no-ekonomicheskoe razvitie yugo-zapadnyh shtatov SShA [Ethno-Demographic Heterogeneity and Socio-Economic Development of the Southwestern States of the USA]. Obshchestvennye nauki i sovremennost’ [Social Sciences and Contemporary World], 5, 128–143. (In Russ.)

Minat, V. N. (2023a). Ocenka stoimostnogo vyrazheniya effekta truda v zdravoohranenii SShA i nera­venstvo obespechennosti medicinskimi uslugami [Assessing the Monetary Value Effect of Labour in Health Care in the USA, and Inequality in the Provision of Medical Services]. Voprosy politicheskoy ekonomii [Problems in Political Economy], 1 (33), 58–77. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7850858 (In Russ.)

Minat, V. N. (2023b). Realizatsiya sotsial’nykh programm v usloviyakh narastayushchey prekarizatsii truda: regional’nye aspekty na primere SShA [Implementation of Social Programs in Conditions of Increasing Labor Precarization: Regional Aspects on the Example of the USA]. Federalizm [Federalism], 28 (2), 139–160. https://doi.org/10.21686/2073-1051-2023-2-139-160 (In Russ.)

Moshenskiy, M. G. (1971). Normirovanie truda i zarabotnaya plata pri kapitalizme [Rationing of Labor and Wages under Capitalism]. Moscow, Russia: Mysl, 333. (In Russ.)

Petrovskaya, N. E. (2021). Molodezhnyy rynok truda v SShA [Youth Labour Market in the United States]. Obshchestvennye nauki i sovremennost’ [Social Sciences and Contemporary World], 2, 66–78. https://doi.org/10.31857/S086904990014322-6 (In Russ.)

Pliskevich, N. M. (2022). Mesto cheloveka v sistemnoj ekonomike [Man in G. Kleiner’s Theory of Economic Systems]. AlterEconomics, 19 (3), 547–562. https://doi.org/10.31063/AlterEconomics/2022.19-3.8 (In Russ.)

Prescott, E. C. (2004). Why Do Americans Work So Much More Than Europeans? Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis. Quarterly Review, 28 (1), 3–33. https://doi.org/10.21034/qr.2811

Rachek, S. V., & Shadrina, A. V. (2022). Nauchnye problemy normirovaniya truda v sovremennyh usloviyah [Scientific Problems of Labor Rationing in Modern Conditions]. Ekaterinburg, Russia: Ural State University of Railway Transport, 167. (In Russ.)

Snir, R., & Harpaz, I. (2012). Beyond workaholism: Towards a general model of heavy work investment. Human Resource Management Review, 22 (3), 232–243. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hrmr.2011.11.011

Sparks, K., Cooper, C. L., Fried, Y., & Shirom, A. (1997). The Effects of Hours of Work on Health: A Meta-Analytic Review. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 70 (4), 391–408. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2044-8325.1997.tb00656.x

Spreg, Sh. (2021). Zamedlenie rosta proizvoditel’nosti truda v SShA: analiz na urovne ekonomiki i otrasley [The Slowdown in U.S. Productivity Growth: An Economic and Sectoral Analysis]. Ekonomist [Economist], 5, 13–53. (In Russ.)

Zubov, V. M. (1990). Kak izmeryaetsya proizvoditel’nost’ truda v SShA [How Labor Productivity is Measured in the United States]. In R. V. Gavrilov (Ed.). Moscow, Russia: Finance and Statistics, 144. (In Russ.)